Sharing is caring!

Looking for the perfect dream gay wedding cake toppers to help make your big day even more special?

I’ve got you covered with these 15 perfect ideas!

Whether you’re looking for cute, clever, traditional or just plain beautiful, you’ll find the perfect LGBTQ+ cake topper below.

Check them out!

Make your big day extra special with dream gay wedding cake toppers! Check out our top 10 favorite most creative & beautiful LGBTQ+ toppers.

Related: Unconventional Wedding Cakes for an Extra Special Reception

Dream Gay Wedding Cake Toppers

To make it easy for you to find your dream gay wedding cake toppers, I’m breaking this up into three sections:

  • Two grooms cake toppers
  • Two brides toppers
  • Gender-neutral wedding cake toppers

Make sense? Good! Let’s get started!

One more quick note, though: this post uses affiliate links. If you make a purchase, we earn a small commission. Thanks!

Two Grooms Wedding Cake Toppers

Start with the table below, then keep reading for more details on each topper!

1. Photo Holder Cake Topper

While there are some super cute figurine-style cake toppers out there, it’s hard to find one that looks exactly like you and your future Mr.!

With this stylish photo holder cake topper, you don’t have to worry about that.

You can put any picture in the holder, but I love the idea of using a photo from when you first met (if you have one).

2. Mr. & Mr. (& their little dog, too!)

Mr and Mr with dog

Want to include your dog in your wedding? Make him a part of your cake topper!

Whether you actually bring him to the big day is up to you, but this adorable topper definitely shows off your love of your furry companion!

Same Sex Gay Wedding Cake Topper - Anniversary Decoration Cake Topper-Mr and Mr Wedding Cake Topper
  • Made of food safe acrylic. It will be the perfect addition to your wedding/anniversary or any party cake.
  • The Gay Wedding Cake Topper is approximately 4.4 inch wide and 6.9 inch high, the bottom tip is about 1.65 inch long.
  • The Gay Wedding Cake Topper is perfect for wedding/anniversary/birthday cake décor , especially for newly-wed bride and groom to make some symbol of the love.
  • After the party, you can keep this unique cake topper forever as a gift, It is reusable.
  • WARRANT: These cake toppers are fragile goods! Because they are fulfilled by Amazon, as a seller we don't know if they are in good condition when you receive. So if they are broken, please feel free to contact us and we'll immediately send you a replacement or refund your purchase price.

3. Personalized Mr. & Mr. Cake Topper

Personalized Mr. & Mr. Cake Topper

Another great silhouette topper, this one is personalized with your names and wedding date.

Just make sure you follow the instructions for personalization after you order.

4. Two Grooms Under a Tree Cake Topper

Two grooms dream gay wedding topper

Can you tell I like silhouette cake toppers?

Like your love, the tree is a shelter against any storms that come your way, and like your marriage, they grow stronger with every passing day.

Sorry, didn’t mean to rhyme there, but you get the drift! The tree is a beautiful marriage symbol.

zhongfei Gay Wedding Cake Topper,Mr & Mr Cake Topper for Groom Gifts,Tree Acrylic Cake Topper
  • Material: Acrylic ( Friendly food safety).
  • Sizes of your cake topper will be 5" to 6" Side to side, 3.5" To 5" top to bottom.suit for 6inch cake
  • Please leave the message to us for all of your custom requests. Your cake topper will be ready in just one or Two business day.
  • There's only black color cake topper in amazon inventory, the customised cake topper is shipped by seller rather than amazon, so it needs several days to deliver your cake topper. If you want to custom one, please leave the message to us for all of your custom requests.
  • Please note: there is a protective film which looks like paper covering the cake topper, it is not wrong color, please remove the film to see the right black color.

5. Silhouette of Love Wedding Cake Topper

Silhouette of Love Gay Wedding Cake Topper

If you want something super classy & beautiful that you can keep for years to come, go with this charming collectible figurine.

It’s made of high-quality porcelain and has incredible reviews on Amazon!

Wedding Collectibles Gay Silhouette of Love Wedding Cake Topper
  • Made of Fine Porcelain
  • Height: 7" - Base Diameter: 3.5"
  • Cake Topper Design By Wedding Collectibles

Two Brides Wedding Cake Toppers

Again, use the table below for a quick peek at my favorite lesbian wedding cake toppers, then keep reading for more details.

6. Moon & Stars Lesbian Cake Topper

I am over the moon about this moon & stars cake topper!

It’s absolutely gorgeous! It’s also perfect for two brides who are both wearing dresses.

Lesbian moon cake topper, wedding cake of the lady and mothers, decoration for wedding cake, decoration for lesbian cake, weddings, lesbian cakes
  • Personalized cake topper
  • Made to order,you can choose the color from our chart
  • Size: 5inch to 6inch Wide
  • Material:Health and Safety Acrylic
  • Please leave the message for the custom items when you ordered

7. Rustic Mrs & Mrs Cake Topper

Planning a rustic wedding? You definitely want this gorgeous wooden cake topper!

If you prefer something a little more personalized, take a look at their Amazon store. They have a few options.

Rustic Wood Mrs. & Mrs. Gay Lesbian Wedding Cake Topper
  • Cake Topper Design By Wedding Collectibles
  • Height: 4.5 inches -Base Diameter: 3.5 inches
  • Made of Wood
  • Made in the USA
  • Rustic Gay Lesbian Wedding Cake Topper - Mrs & Mrs

8. Mrs. & Mrs. Diamond Rings Topper

lesbian wedding cake toppers

Prefer something with a little more bling? Try this diamond rings topper.

It comes in a book-shaped box so you can keep it for years after your big day.

LOVENJOY Gift Box Pack Lesbian Mrs and Mrs in Diamond Rings Same Sex Monogram Wedding Engagement Cake Topper (5.3-inch, Silver Glitter)
  • Monogram Mrs and Mrs with diamond rings
  • Made from a 1/8-inch thick silver giltter Acrylic, food safe and lightweight; approx 5.3-inch wide by 4.3-inch high, perfectly sized for multi-tier cake
  • Goes great with same sex wedding theme, a great nice touch to cake ideas for weddings, anniversaries, engagements or birthday parties
  • Arrives in a book-shaped box, ready for gift giving with an attached wish paper for you to write down best wishes or marriage vows, perfect gift for newly-weds
  • Along with the wishes or vows, sure to become a lifetime keepsake of the special day that will sit on bookshelf with some wedding photos; please read below description prior to purchasing

9. Mrs & Mrs Under the Tree

dream gay wedding cake toppers

This is the “two brides” version of the tree cake topper that I mentioned above.

It’s not a huge topper, so it’s perfect for a “cake smash” cake (or a smaller wedding cake).

Mrs & Mrs Couple Lesbian Cake Topper Under The Tree Wood Cake Topper After Forever Love Cake Photo Prop Decoration.
  • 🎉 TRANSFORM A CAKE INTO A CLASSY ONE - Add a touch of something specical Cake Topper as the finishing touch to your beautiful cake. It’s the perfect way to help celebrate the atmosphere into the wedding/birthday party.
  • 🎉 GET COMPLIMENTS ON YOUR CAKE - No cake is complete without a topper to mark the occasion. Whether you have a lavishly decorated cake or a simple one, this topper will be guaranteed to get everybody jealous!
  • 🎉 GREAT PROP FOR ‘CAKE SMASH’ PHOTO SHOOT - Many of us wish we had cake smash parties in our day! Well now, just experience it with your friends get some amazing photos to prove how much fun it is!
  • 🎉 GET THE GLITZ WITHOUT THE MESS - You’ll love how the topper glistens in the light or sunshine, which is perfect when you want those sparkles to stand out at the Wedding Party. And we’ve carefully made every topper so that the glitter stays on the topper and won’t fall off onto the cake.
  • 🎉 DELICATE AND LIGHTWEIGHT FOR ALL CAKES - Beautifully made, the topper is one sided, yet lightweight and elegantly designed so it stands up and won’t topple over on your birthday cake. WARRANTY- 100 percent satisfaction: All cake topper was carefully checked before going up to sell, If they do not meet your need, our customer service are hassle free for you to resolve your issue. If you are not satisfied with our cake topper received, you can apply for unconditional return and reimbur

10. Custom Date Lesbian Cake Topper

Custom Date Lesbian Cake Topper

Will one of you be wearing pants or a suit instead of a dress?

This beautiful silhouette topper is perfect, and you can customize it with your wedding date!

Lesbian Cake Topper With Date,Lesbian Wedding Cake Topper,Same Sex + Date Cake Topper,Mrs And Mrs Cake Topper, Wood Cake Topper
  • Material: Acrylic or wood
  • Size: Approx.5-6 inches
  • Stunning cake topper in cute and attractive Bride and Groom shape.Top-class acrylic stick material. Non-toxic and safe for food use.
  • Place the order and email us the customize information to us within 24 housrs
  • Delicately crafted bride and groom design. Make your cake decoration more pretty and warming.Perfect cake picks for wedding, engagement, Valentine's Day and other ceremony days for lovers.

Gender-neutral Dream Gay Wedding Toppers

You know the drill! Use the table to check them out at a glance, then keep reading!

11. Rainbow Cake Topper

rainbow cake topper

So, I’m kind of annoyed because all of the rainbow cake toppers are basically made for a unicorn party and I wanted something a little classier.

Then I thought, you know what? Who cares if it’s for a child’s birthday party? It’s still whimsical, fun, and celebrates your pride.

You can easily leave off the balloons and clouds if you want, or toss them on for totally fun vibe.

Colorful Rainbow Cake Topper Birthday Wedding Cake Flags Cloud Balloon cake flag Birthday Party Baking Decoration Supplies
  • Rainbow is made by soft clay. Cloud is made by paperboard. And balloon is made by foam.
  • This cake topper set arrange rainbow, clouds and colorful balloons in groups. Its harmonize colors and peaceful combination will make your cake pretty and cute.
  • Package include 1pcs Rainbow Cake Topper, 5pcs Clouds Cake Topper and 6pcs Balloon Cake Topper.

12. Engraved Wooden Cake Topper

This one is similar to the “Mrs. & Mrs.” rustic cake topper above, except you can have your initials and date engraved onto it.

It’s a fantastic choice for a rustic wedding and makes a nice keepsake after the big day.

Personalized Wood Custom Rustic Wedding Cake Topper
  • Cake Topper Design By Wedding Collectibles
  • Height: 4.5 inches -Base Diameter: 3.5 inches
  • Made of Wood
  • Made in the USA

13. Our Adventure Begins

Your wedding marks the start of a beautiful adventure together, so let your cake tell the world that you’re ready for anything!

Check the description for details on how you can customize this with different colors and text.

And so Our Adventure Begins Cake Topper, Wedding Cake Topper, Customised Anniversary Cake Decorations, Engagement Topper Gifts
  • Customize: All Our Personalized Cake Toppers are made to order just for your wedding with your last name and date.Our default color is as the main image shown,if you don't choose the color and message when you order it,we will arrange the default color for you.
  • The normal color is 2.5 mm thick acrylic, The mirror color is 1.8 mm thick acrylic ,Width : 5"-6" Side to side (The exact height of this topper will depend on what width is chosen and what last name is used.) You also can choose the corresponding acrylic and wood color according to our color chart from the secend and third images.There are two stakes attached to the bottom of this cake topper. Please note the stakes are not removable on this topper.
  • When you checkout, please supply a Note to Seller with the Name to appear on the topper. Also, please let us know what date you need the topper! This information will be helpful when we need to rush your cake topper. If you want to get it faster,please contact us.
  • Perfect gift for weddings, anniversaries, valentine's day gift or birthday parties,Especially for newly-wed bride and groom.It is easy to clean, and can be used as home decoration for a lifetime after weddings or parties.
  • If you have a custom design in mind, send it to us in a message and we will be happy to work with you to create a cake topper custom tailored to you! If you have any questions for the shipping and product,please contact me asap.I will solve your problem for you at the first time.Thank you so much for your help!

14. To the Moon and Back

dream gay wedding topper

You love each other to the moon and back, and this one makes sure that everyone knows it!

Glitter Silver To the Moon&Back Romantic Wedding Cake Topper, Elegant Cake Topper For Wedding Anniversary, Wedding Party Decorative Cake Toppers, Birthday Cake Topper Acrylic Cake Topper
  • Made of food safe acrylic. It will be the perfect addition to your wedding anniversary or any party cake.
  • The letters are approximately 4.9" wide and 4.7" high. The bottom tip is about 2" long.
  • It's a GREAT addition to the tiered wedding cake.
  • The cake toppers are perfect for wedding/anniversary/bridal/shower/birthday cake décor , especially for newly-wed bride and groom to make some symbol of the love.
  • After The Party, You Can Keep This Unique Cake Topper Forever As A Gift, It Is Reusable.

15. Always…

Now for my favorite dream wedding cake topper, a little something for my fellow Wizarding World fans.

I’ve read the Harry Potter series a dozen times and seen the movie just as many, and every single time this line makes me tear up.

Always Wedding Cake Topper, After All This Time Always Cake Topper, Wedding/Anniversary/Bridal shower/Birthday Cake Topper
  • Made of food safe acrylic. It will be the perfect addition to your wedding anniversary or any party cake.
  • It's approximately 6.4" wide and 5.5" high.
  • The cake topper is perfect for a wedding/anniversary/bridal/shower/birthday cake décor , especially for newly-wed bride and groom to make some symbol of love.
  • Suit for magical theme wedding/anniversary/bridal shower/birthday party.
  • After the party, you can keep this unique cake topper forever as a gift, It is reusable.

Nicole is the editor-in-chief and regular staff writer for LoveYouWedding. What does that mean? Basically, she handles all the day-to-day tasks related to managing writers and bringing you stellar content on planning the LGBTQ+ wedding of your dreams.

She loves writing about quirky and unique wedding ideas, probably because she’s pretty quirky herself!

Sharing is caring!

Last update on 2021-06-24 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API